00551 Three Fatal Problems of Pre-Tax IRAs: Required Minimum Distribution (RMD), High Tax Rates, and Double Taxation!

I. Current Theme

#

This episode revolves around two core themes: First, specific investment and financial management strategies, focusing on revealing the huge tax traps existing in US Traditional (Pre-tax) retirement accounts—specifically the “Estate Tax + Income Tax” double taxation issue faced during inheritance—and emphasizing the importance of prioritizing funds into Roth accounts. Second, the course deeply explores the meaning of life and lifestyle after financial freedom, guiding investors to think further about how to break free from the shackles of work, find inner peace and joy, and realize true life value after solving their financial problems.

II. Briefing Content

#

Blood Sugar Control Experience Sharing

#

• Monitoring Tools: James shared his experience using continuous glucose monitors (such as Stero or Abbott) for over a week, emphasizing that their value lies not in the absolute value of a single number, but in observing the trends of blood sugar changes throughout the day to help maintain stability.
• Target Range: The teacher’s personal blood sugar control goal is to keep fluctuations between 115 and 140 throughout the day while awake, ensuring it does not exceed 140 even one hour after meals.
• Control Methods (Personal experience, not medical advice):
  1. Pre-meal Preparation: 15-20 minutes before a meal, drink a mixture of 350-500cc water, one tablespoon of sugar-free apple cider vinegar, and two teaspoons of sugar-free fiber (Costco’s Metamucil sugar-free version is recommended). Drink immediately to prevent the fiber from thickening.
  2. Eating Order: Eat vegetables first, then protein (fish, meat, eggs), and finally a small amount of carbohydrates (such as rice, bread).
  3. Oil Pairing: Adding a small amount of high-quality oil (like olive oil) to rice or bread can slow down carbohydrate digestion, making the blood sugar rise smoother.
  4. Exercise: Walking before and after meals helps accelerate the drop in blood sugar.

Hong Kong High Dividend ETFs and AI Asset Allocation

#

• Hong Kong Market: The teacher mentioned that although he previously thought China’s high dividend strategy might fail, Hong Kong market’s high dividend ETFs (such as 3416, 9416, 883) are still performing well, with dividend yields as high as 16.8% and annualized returns near 20%, which serves as a reference for Hong Kong investors.
• Using AI for Asset Planning:
  • The teacher demonstrated how to use AI tools like ChatGPT to solve asset allocation problems.
  • Steps: Input all personal asset details (cash, stocks, real estate, etc.) into the AI, then ask specific questions.
  • Prompt Examples:
    1. “Please calculate my total investment assets, total assets, and the ratio of annual expenses to total assets.”
    2. “If I need an annual cash flow of 7%, what should be the asset portfolio ratio between Investment A (like QQQ, 12% annualized return) and Investment B (like the 433 allocation, capable of withdrawing 2% annually)? How much capital needs to be invested in each target (QQQ, 00662, 00672L, 00651L, etc.)?”
  • AI can quickly and accurately provide detailed asset allocation plans, greatly facilitating personal financial planning.

The Trap of US Retirement Accounts: Double Taxation Risk of Pre-tax Accounts

#

• Core Recommendation: For salaried employees in the US, if you have money, you should prioritize maxing out Roth accounts (Roth 401K, Roth IRA), followed by putting funds into a regular Brokerage Account. Absolutely do not put a single cent into Traditional retirement accounts (Traditional IRA, Pre-tax 401K).
• Disadvantages of Pre-tax Accounts:
  1. RMD (Required Minimum Distribution): At age 75, you are forced to withdraw a certain percentage of funds annually. If the account holds millions or even tens of millions of dollars, the amount required to be withdrawn annually could be hundreds of thousands or even millions, which will be taxed at an extremely high marginal tax rate, far higher than the tax rate when you were young.
  2. Difficulty in Conversion: The teacher used himself as an example, noting it would take over 30 years to gradually convert Pre-tax account funds to Roth, a long and painful process. If one wants to convert $2 million in assets within 10 years (assuming 15% annualized growth), nearly $350,000 needs to be converted annually, resulting in a heavy tax burden.
  3. Double Taxation Risk on Inheritance (Poison Pill):
     • When a Pre-tax account is passed to children as inheritance, it faces extremely serious tax issues.
     • Scenario 1: If the total estate exceeds the exemption amount (e.g., $13 million), the excess is first subject to a high Estate Tax.
     • Scenario 2: After paying the estate tax, the heir must also withdraw all remaining funds in the account (including principal and appreciation) within 10 years and pay Income Tax on it, because this money has never been taxed.
     • Conclusion: This constitutes double taxation, levied by the IRS under the names of “Estate Tax” and “Income Tax” respectively, which is a huge blow to wealth inheritance. Therefore, Pre-tax accounts are a “poison” that should be avoided at all costs in financial planning.

III. Q&A Session

#

M

#

• Question: When life encounters a “Black Swan” event, such as a beloved pet needing an expensive surgery with a low success rate, how should one balance emotional conscience with rational financial planning? How to choose between treatment and letting go?
• James’ Reply:
  1. Step 1: Face it: Do not escape; face the current predicament squarely.
  2. Step 2: Solve it (Assess Capability): Honestly assess your scope of capability, including financial capacity and emotional endurance. If the problem is within your ability, try your best to solve it.
  3. Step 3: Let it go: If the matter is beyond your ability and cannot be solved no matter how hard you try, then learn to let go. Obsessing over things that cannot be changed only increases pain.
  • The teacher added that life is full of things we cannot control, just like the international situation. We need to clearly define the boundaries of our capabilities. For pets, everyone positions them differently (as family or companion animals), which determines the limit of what one is willing to pay. The important thing is not to force yourself; do your best within your capabilities, and then accept the result.

Y

#

• Question: Regarding Taiwan’s Labor Insurance Pension, the teacher sometimes suggests withdrawing it as a lump sum to invest in 00662, and sometimes suggests claiming it monthly. What is the logic behind this judgment? Is it related to total assets?
• James’ Reply:
  • The key to this suggestion lies not in the amount of assets, but in the individual’s “Investment Literacy” and “Investment Experience”.
  • Monthly Claim Candidates: People with insufficient investment experience, poor financial literacy, past investment failures, or inability to control their emotions and spending. For them, having a large sum of money is high risk; it might soon be lost due to panic, greed, or squandering. Stable monthly cash flow is safer “survival money.”
  • Lump Sum Candidates: Investors who have undergone long-term study and practice, have a stable investment mindset, and fully understand and adhere to long-term investment philosophy. They can invest the lump sum into QQQ or QQQI, and theoretically, the long-term return will be better than monthly claims (because besides dividends, there is long-term share price growth).
  • The teacher emphasized that theoretically, the difference in returns between the two methods is not large (the actuarial return rate of labor insurance is about 12%), the core difference lies in whether the investor can manage this money well.

Brian

#

• Sharing: Recently met a financial advisor at a social event claiming an annualized return of 40-50%, which made him appreciate the teacher’s philosophy even more. He realized that the key to investment is not pursuing high returns, but surviving in the worst-case scenarios (like a 50% market drop).
• James’ Comment: Voices from the outside world are often one-sided. The other party might only be talking about the Return on Investment (ROI) of a small amount of speculative capital, ignoring the larger portion of conservative assets. Investment should look at the long-term annualized return of the entire portfolio, not the myth of a single year or a single target. Facing these disturbances, one must cultivate the ability to be “unmoved like a mountain.” In the beginner stage, one can “not listen, not look,” but in the advanced stage, one must practice “listening and looking, yet mind dwelling nowhere,” remaining inwardly unmoved.

CAD

#

• Sharing: She agrees that while short-term traders might get excess returns, their lives are filled with huge pressure and a cycle of “bankruptcy-riches,” which is far less relaxed and effortless than our long-term investment method, which has the highest CP value (performance-price ratio). She suggests that everyone need not try to change others, but simply walk their own path firmly.
• James’ Comment: This is “acting without getting into character.” More importantly, the first element of investment success is not learning specific methods, but establishing a ‘Wealthy Mindset’. You must believe from the bottom of your heart that you deserve wealth and love money, so that wealth will draw near to you. If your subconscious believes money is evil, no matter what investment method you use, you will eventually lose it all.

Maomao

#

• Sharing: She raised a profound philosophical thought: How should one live when passive income covers daily expenses? She believes AI will replace most jobs, and humans will face an “existential crisis”—when you are no longer your job identity (engineer, driver), then who are you? She believes that happiness after retirement should not come from fleeting dopamine stimulation (like travel, gaming), but from an eternal inner state. She proposed two directions:
  1. Finding “Flow”: Entering a state of high focus through activities that bring immediate positive feedback (like rock climbing, sports, deep conversation with AI) to gain pleasure and a sense of achievement.
  2. Practicing “Homecoming”: Practicing feeling joy, completeness, and peace simply because of “existence” itself, because of “breathing,” reaching a state of oneness with the environment.
• James’ Comment: The teacher expressed great appreciation for Maomao having such profound insights in her 30s. He further elaborated that life’s happiness and sense of existence come from “Being Present.” Most people are just “walking dead” at work and haven’t truly “lived.” Happiness is a human right; breathing is happiness. The arrival of the AI era is to liberate humans from the “slavery” and “curse” of work, allowing us to return to the essence of life—thinking, feeling, creating, and enjoying happiness. This is not a crisis, but an opportunity for humanity to enter “Heaven on Earth.”

Dixon

#

• Question: He is 27 years old and has achieved financial freedom through his parents’ funding (10 million RMB). However, he currently holds a software engineer job with an annual salary of 500k RMB but immense pressure, and is conflicted about whether to resign. He worries: 1. Losing high salary will slow down asset accumulation; 2. Early retirement means finding no meaning in life; 3. He won’t find such a good job again later.
• James’ Reply:
  • “You don’t need to work anymore!” The teacher answered decisively. Health and life are far more important than money you no longer need. High-pressure work is “torturing” your body and is extremely unworthy.
  • He advised Dixon to resign immediately, leave the fast lane, to see the scenery along the way, and to discover what he truly wants to do.
  • He also encouraged young people to bravely experience life, including getting married and having children. These are important parts of the amusement park of life, worth experiencing whether good or bad. For Dixon, the priority is to take care of himself and find happiness, not to work for money. Using AI skills, one person can command an army and create infinite possibilities.

Dick

#

• Sharing: Shared the experience of accompanying a friend with cancer through the final journey. This process made him deeply realize: 1. Real estate has very poor liquidity when money is urgently needed and is not a good asset; 2. The philosophy of “Face it, Deal with it, Let it go” taught by the teacher is very important, although hard to practice. He is grateful that he had the ability to accompany his friend as best as he could, bringing closure to both.
• James’ Comment: The teacher praised Dick for being full of positive energy. He emphasized that “Face, Solve, Let go” is a compulsory course in life, and one even needs to practice through meditation and simulation before things happen to strengthen inner power, so as to face any loss with a smile.

Doris

#

• Sharing:
  1. She shared her views on marriage and work from the perspective of “Genesis”: Marriage is a beautiful relationship established by God to solve the problem of “it is not good for man to be alone”; while work is a “curse” after humans were expelled from the Garden of Eden, to toil for a living. The liberation brought by AI might be a sign that humans are completing their “atonement” and are about to return to paradise.
  2. She observed that even her 83-year-old mother, who hasn’t touched stocks for over 20 years, recently started buying stocks. This makes her think whether this is a signal that the market is overheating and nearing a peak (similar to the “shoe shine boy talking about stocks” indicator).
• James’ Comment: He agreed with Doris’s sharing and added that we are indeed entering a “Heaven on Earth” where we can get rid of the curse of labor, and we should feel happy about it. At the same time, he reminded parents to take their children outdoors more and get rid of dependence on electronic devices.

Tao

#

• Sharing: He is very grateful for the teacher’s course, stating it allowed his investment cognition to evolve from an “ape” to a “human,” learning systematic investment and risk control.
• Questions & Teacher’s Replies:
  1. Question: Do QQQ and QQQI both have systemic risks based on the Nasdaq 100 index?
     • Reply: Yes, this is the system’s only weakness. If US tech is destroyed, we are all destroyed; this is a risk that cannot be diversified. However, QQQI’s dividends come from option premiums and some capital gains, not company dividends, so its dividend distribution is relatively stable.
  2. Question: As a new immigrant with very little money in the Roth account, how should I allocate?
     • Reply: A Roth account with little capital should be 100% invested in QQQ (or QQQD); do not leave cash. The cash part of the 433 allocation (“3”) should be placed in a brokerage account, where you can buy ETFs like BILS that use capital appreciation instead of distributing dividends to achieve tax optimization.
  3. Question: How should the leverage part (“3”, like QLD) in the 433 allocation be bought and allocated?
     • Reply: It is not recommended to hold leveraged ETFs (like QLD) in a regular Brokerage Account because selling during rebalancing will generate a high tax burden. The leveraged part should be allocated in tax-advantaged retirement accounts (like Roth IRA). Invest the money put into the IRA annually as a lump sum.
  4. Question: When using margin loans in the US, is the entire account pledged or partial assets? Will rebalancing be affected?
     • Reply: In the US, it is usually the entire account that serves as collateral (Portfolio Margin), unlike in Taiwan where specific stocks need to be allocated. This does not affect your freedom to buy and sell stocks within the account for rebalancing.

IV. Highlighted Views

#

Pre-tax retirement accounts (in the US) are a disaster, a poison, do not touch them… When it becomes an inheritance, it will be double taxed. – Teacher James

This view is the highest level of warning regarding the tax risks of US traditional retirement accounts, revealing the potentially devastating consequences for wealth inheritance.

Facing problems… if it can be solved, we solve it; if it cannot be solved, we let it go. – Teacher James

This is the trilogy of life problem-solving proposed by the teacher, a simple yet powerful life philosophy that helps people free themselves from endless worries.

Happiness is a human right… you are happy just by breathing. – Teacher James

This view elevates happiness to the level of a fundamental right and points out that the source of happiness can be very simple and internal: living in the moment and feeling one’s own existence.

When you are no longer the identity of your job, when you are no longer an engineer or a driver, then who are you really? – Maomao

This sentence profoundly points out the deep crisis of identity and existential meaning that modern people are about to face in the post-work era.

Work is the biggest waste of life… The generation where humans don’t need to work is coming, this is returning to humanism. – Teacher James

This view subverts traditional work ethics, believing that AI liberating humans from labor is historical progress, enabling humans to return to thinking and enjoying the essence of life.

Taking good care of your body is more important than wealth… Money is no longer important to you. – Teacher James

This is advice to a young man who is financially free but still troubled by high-pressure work, emphasizing the primary value of life and health.

The first thing to succeed in investment is not learning, but establishing a wealthy mindset. – Teacher James

This view emphasizes that the root of investment success lies within, meaning “mindset is greater than method,” and having a positive and deserving concept of wealth is the foundation of all investment strategies.

You entered the amusement park of life, and there is a huge chunk, half of it, that you haven’t experienced. It’s actually a pity. – Teacher James

This is a metaphor the teacher uses to encourage young people to bravely experience life, including marriage and family, believing that these experiences themselves are precious treasures of life and should not be missed due to fear.

V. Summary

#

This episode began with an extremely important financial warning—the double taxation trap of US Pre-tax retirement accounts—sounding the alarm for investors’ long-term wealth planning. Subsequently, the focus of the course shifted to a more profound exploration of life philosophy. Through the sharing of multiple students and the teacher’s guidance, we jointly thought about how to redefine the meaning of work after financial freedom, how to face uncertainties in life, and how to find lasting happiness that transcends material things and originates from within. This is not just an investment class, but a spiritual cleansing on how to “live,” encouraging us to break free from social shackles and bravely pursue a freer, truer, and happier life.